About Toothpicks

Toothpicks Catering is a social catering company, small enough for a personal touch, with the experience to ensure every event is something special.  We are pleased to offer Chef-prepared and artistically presented meals made with only the best ingredients - local ingredients- whenever possible.  We provide creative menus for your family, your workplace, and your special events.

Services Offered

Catering and Event Planning services is the heart of our business.  Whether you are planning a small cocktail party, a wedding, or corporate event, we are here to make your day the best it can be...leave the details to us.  The addition of our private dining studio makes a nice venue for events with 40 or less guests, this space is a nice alternative to a loud public restaurant.  

Toothpicks is pleased to announce that we have partnered with the historic East Troy Electric Railroad in providing a fine dining experience.  Please visit to learn more about it.  Chartered trains are a fun option for your next private event!

Toothpicks Catering knows how hectic life can be, often times resulting in fast food or unhealthy meal choices for  our families. The rising need for fresh, convenient, and sustainable foods has led us to launch our program, 

'Dinner with Family'.  Every Wednesday from 4:00pm to 7:00pm a Chef-inspired and created meal is available for pick-up at our commercial kitchen (East Troy).  Meals are priced to feed a family of four, you must pre-order at least 48 hours in advance by calling or texting 262-370-2994. Prefer email? Please email us at  Our menu is also upload weekly to facebook.

The Faces of Toothpicks

Allow us to introduce ourselves, we are Sarah Cain and Erica Stamm. We founded Toothpicks Catering in 2011.  With many years of catering, restaurant management and hospitality experience, we bring a diverse perspective to each event. Our passion for the industry led us to partner together and create a one of a kind business.  Our catering staff's attention to detail, friendliness, and attentiveness makes our company one of a kind. We are proud of our company, and look forward to working with you.  




Whether you are looking to have Toothpicks come to your home, place of business, or you would like to reserve our private dining studio, the first step will be booking your date! Give us a call or email us today to reserve your spot on our calendar.


We welcome any feedback from our guests. Email, call, or post on our facebook page. We look forward to hearing from you!